CALL NOW: (219) 879-5357

As your local Michigan City Allstate agency we can help you with your insurance needs

About me

Paula Wagner - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Agent
PSA Paula Wagner 1812 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, IN, 46360
Call: (219) 879-5357(219) 879-5357
Other Locations
Send Me An EmailSend Me An Email

I have operated an Allstate Insurance agency in Michigan City, Indiana since 2010. My agency helps people with their insurance - home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, and much more. Our service-oriented insurance agency is owned and operated by my family and me. We try to make customers feel like part of our family.

I’m proud to offer Allstate products, because they stand by their service. As an Allstate customer, when you’re in need, you can take advantage of a variety of repair options for a damaged home or auto. From selecting a repair shop, to workmanship guarantees – it just makes sense to work with Allstate.

I’m committed to helping you protect what you have today and prepare for tomorrow. I understand the importance of thinking about the “big picture” when it comes to your financial future. From life insurance to retirement, I’m committed to helping you reach your financial goals.

Community Services:
Michigan City Chamber of Commerce

Spoken Languages:

*For financial product transactions in a language other than English, customers must use an interpreter.

My Team

Jennifer Reid - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Team
Jennifer Reid Office Manager Property & Casualty Insurance - Life Insurance Specialist
Jami Anderson - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Team
Jami Anderson Customer Service Representative Customer Service - Claims - Reviews
Robert Coddington - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Team
Robert Coddington Licensed Support Staff Life Specialist
Chris Havens - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Team
Chris Havens Property & Casualty & Life Property, Casualty & Life Specialist
Richard Tabor - Michigan City, IN - Allstate Team
Richard Tabor Customer Service Customer Service Specialist


Business Hours
8:30 a.m.
5:30 p.m.
8:30 a.m.
5:30 p.m.
8:30 a.m.
5:30 p.m.
8:30 a.m.
5:30 p.m.
8:30 a.m.
4:30 p.m.
Available By Appointment: Saturday, Sunday

Business Location Map

Follow Us On


Insurance is unlike any other product out there - you pay for it and hope you never have to use it. And that makes paying more than you need to that much more uncomfortable.
With a policy from Allstate, you can help keep your insurance costs low with the wide variety of discounts we offer. Keep in mind, not all discounts are available in every state. The best way to get all that you qualify for is to get an insurance quote specific to Michigan City.
You can get a rough "ballpark" insurance quote from many companies online, but talking with an agent allows you to ask questions and get a quote for coverage that matters most to you. An agent can prepare a quote that details the coverage, deductibles (your portion of a loss) and cost (premium) of your insurance policy.

Areas Served

  • Michigan City, IN
  • Trail Creek, IN
  • Long Beach, IN
  • Chesterton, IN
  • Grand Beach, MI
  • Pottawattamie Park, IN
  • Michiana, MI
  • Valparaiso, IN
  • 46360
  • 46391
  • 46301
  • 49117
  • 46371
  • Products Offered

    Auto Insurance
    Car Insurance
    Life Insurance
    Insurance Agent
    College Savings Plans
    Business Insurance
    Featured Video

    Visit Allstate Youtube channel
    Save up to 30% when you combine insurance policies.
    Call Now: (219) 879-5357 or
    Show All

    Paula Wagner is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Illinois, Indiana, and Michigan. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Illinois, Indiana, or Michigan, please go to the Find an Agent section on to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

    Subject to terms, conditions & availability.

    This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). Life insurance issued by Allstate Life Insurance Company: Northbrook, IL; and American Heritage Life Insurance Company: Jacksonville, FL. In New York, Allstate Life Insurance Company of New York: Hauppauge, NY. Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 2920 South 84th Street, Lincoln, NE 68506. (877) 525-5727.

    Allstate and its affiliates do not render tax or legal advice. Please consult with your tax and legal advisors regarding your personal circumstance.