CALL NOW: (937) 434-5242

As your local Centerville Allstate agency we can help you with your insurance needs

About me

Steve Fenstemaker - Centerville, OH - Allstate Agent
PSA Steve Fenstemaker CLTC 1031 S Main St
Centerville, OH, 45458
Call: (937) 434-5242(937) 434-5242
Fax: (937) 434-5032
Additional Contact Info
Other Locations
Send Me An EmailSend Me An Email

Our family has worked closely with Allstate for years to help people with their insurance needs – from homes to auto to boats and more. Our quality, service-oriented agency is not only owned and operated by a family, customers tell us we make them feel like family too.

I’m proud to work with a company who’s been serving satisfied customers for over 80 years. Customers count on outstanding financial strength and superior claims service to help protect what they value most. Allstate delivers on their promise. In fact, their outstanding financial strength and superior claims service received an A+ (Superior) rating by A.M. Best. Quality service, strength and satisfaction – that’s something I’m glad to be a part of.

I’m committed to showing you how Allstate is different and better than the rest. From sharing our broad product offerings for your protection and financial needs to offering you a real relationship you can count on. I’ll help you prepare for your financial future and offer a higher standard of service, delivered wherever and whenever you need.

Honor Ring-12 Years
Chairman's Inner Circle-1 Year
National Conference Award-12 Years
Chairman's Conference-5 Years
Allstate Leader's Forum-7 Years
Allstate Financial Leader Award-7 Years

Civic Services:
Association of Naval Aviators
Optimist International
South Metro Chamber of Commerce
Dayton Chamber of Commerce
Miami Valley Consumer Group

Community Services:
Centerville Citizen's Police Academy Alumni
Centerville Citizen's Police Academy Alumni Assn
Centerville Community Church
Centerville Safety Council
Centerville Noon Optimist
Association of Naval Aviators
Naval Academy Alumni Assn
2000 Plus - Men Against Domestic Violence

Industry Services:
Dayton Area Chamber of Commerce
South Metro Regional Chamber of Commerce
Dayton Mortgage Bankers Association
National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors
Dayton Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors
Miami Valley Consumer Group
Insurance Institute of America
Business Network International

Bachelor of Science-United States Naval Academy

Commercial Insurance

Spoken Languages:

*For financial product transactions in a language other than English, customers must use an interpreter.

My Team

Karen Fenstemaker - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Karen Fenstemaker Administrative Assistant
Eric Lowman - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Eric Lowman Personal Financial Representative
Ashland DeRossett - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Ashland DeRossett Senior Customer Service Representative
Joey Rettig - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Joey Rettig Senior Licensed Sales Associate
John Cannon - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
John Cannon Senior Customer Service Representative
Nora Rees - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Nora Rees Licensed Sales Associate
Herm Branham - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Herm Branham Senior Customer Service Representative
Brian Selzer - Centerville, OH - Allstate Team
Brian Selzer Licensed Sales Associate
Business Hours
9:00 a.m.
5:00 p.m.
9:00 a.m.
5:00 p.m.
9:00 a.m.
5:00 p.m.
9:00 a.m.
5:00 p.m.
9:00 a.m.
5:00 p.m.
9:00 a.m.
12:00 p.m.
Available By Appointment: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday

Business Location Map

Follow Us On


Insurance is unlike any other product out there - you pay for it and hope you never have to use it. And that makes paying more than you need to that much more uncomfortable.
With a policy from Allstate, you can help keep your insurance costs low with the wide variety of discounts we offer. Keep in mind, not all discounts are available in every state. The best way to get all that you qualify for is to get an insurance quote specific to Centerville.
You can get a rough "ballpark" insurance quote from many companies online, but talking with an agent allows you to ask questions and get a quote for coverage that matters most to you. An agent can prepare a quote that details the coverage, deductibles (your portion of a loss) and cost (premium) of your insurance policy.

Areas Served

  • Ohio
  • Michigan
  • Indiana
  • Florida
  • Virginia
  • California
  • Kentucky
  • Massachusets
  • Missouri
  • 45458
  • 45459
  • 45066
  • 45305
  • 45440
  • Products Offered

    Auto Insurance
    Car Insurance
    Life Insurance
    Insurance Agent
    College Savings Plans
    Business Insurance
    Featured Video

    Visit Allstate Youtube channel
    Save up to 30% when you combine insurance policies.
    Call Now: (937) 434-5242 or
    Show All

    Steve Fenstemaker is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Arizona, Ohio, and South Carolina. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Arizona, Ohio, or South Carolina, please go to the Find an Agent section on to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

    Subject to terms, conditions & availability.

    This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). Life insurance and annuities issued by Allstate Life Insurance Company: Northbrook, IL; Lincoln Benefit Life Insurance Company: Lincoln, NE; and American Heritage Life Insurance Company: Jacksonville, FL. In New York, Allstate Life Insurance Company of New York: Hauppauge, NY. Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 2920 South 84th Street, Lincoln, NE 68506. (877) 525-5727.

    You should carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses of 529 college savings plans before purchasing or investing money. Additional information about these and other subjects can be found in the Plan Description. You may obtain copies of the Plan Description from your Allstate Personal Financial Representative. Please read the Plan Description carefully before purchasing or sending money.

    Investors should consider whether the investor's or designated beneficiary's home state offers any state tax or other benefits that are only available with an investment in the home state's plan.
    Distributions taken prior to annuitization are generally considered to come from the gain in the contact first. If the contract is tax-qualified, generally withdrawals are treated as distributions of gain. Withdrawals of gain are taxed as ordinary income and, if taken prior to age 59 1/2, may be subject to an additional 10% federal tax penalty.

    Any annuity payment is dependent on the ability of the issuer to pay its claims. An annuity may impose charges (including but not limited to surrender charges, mortality and expense risk charges, administrative fees, underlying fund expenses and feature charges) that can reduce the value of your account and the return on your investment.