Allstate Insurance Agent
Donn SharerMillstone Township, NJ


Office Hours

Day of the WeekHours
MonAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
TueAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
WedAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
ThuAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
FriAvailable by appointment9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
SatAvailable by appointment
After-hours appointments available.
Available 24/7 at

500 State Route 33,
Ste 1D
Millstone Township, NJ 08535

Other Locations

Areas Served

Millstone, Monroe, Manalapan, East Windsor, Freehold


We are located on the west bound side of State Route 33 approximately .5 miles past Smithburg Road (Rte 527). If you reach Dugans Grove, you've gone about .3 miles too far.

Additional Contact

Fax: (732) 446-7294
Donn Sharer: Allstate Insurance
You can view my financial industry experience and background at FINRA’s BrokerCheck

Local Allstate Agent: Meet Donn Sharer

Products we offer:

  • Auto
  • Home
  • Condo
  • Renters
  • Motorcycle
  • Business
  • Life
  • ATV
  • Boat
Years of
Years in the
Education dropdown expand/collapse
Bachelor of Science-Northwestern University
Master of Business Administration-University of Minnesota
Community Involvement
Community Involvement dropdown expand/collapse
Family Promise of Southern Ocean County
Elks Army of Hope
Children's Miracle Network Hospitals
Mary's Place by the Sea
OceanCares Foundation
Emiliana's Hope
Michael's Feat
Civic Services
Civic Services dropdown expand/collapse
Achilles International - Secretary, Board of Directors
Menttium - international mentoring program
Millstone Township Foundation For Educational Excellence (MTFEE)
Millstone Twp. Fire Co Ladies Auxiliary

Our team

Donn Sharer

Agency Owner
Donn, a graduate of Northwestern University with an MBA from the University of Minnesota, has worked in insurance since the late 1990s. He splits his time between the Forked River agency and his Millstone Township agency, Sharer & Associates, Inc. which opened in 2005. When not at work, Donn is an avid runner and enjoys riding roller coasters with his children and playing Sudoku.

Bob Considine

Agency Owner
Bob, a graduate of Boston College, is a life-long resident of Lacey Township and has been in the insurance industry since the late 1990s. He founded and built the Considine Financial Group into an Allstate Premier Service Agency. When not at work, Bob enjoys spending time with family and is heavily involved in his community, serving as a soccer and basketball coach, as well as the youth activities director for the Elks Youth Activity Committee.

Robin Sharer

Office Manager - Sharer & Associates Inc
A graduate of Yale University, Robin has been with our agency since 2005. Her background in commodity trading gives her solid, transferable skills to the insurance industry. She also has experience in retail product management. She would be happy to help you in any way she can

Liz Wiemken

Senior Account Representative
A graduate of St. John’s University, Liz has been in the insurance industry since 2000. When not in the office, she enjoys spending time with her family, running, and reading. Customer service is her priority.

Angela Compolattaro

Licensed Sales Professional
Angela was born and raised in Brick and moved to Toms River in 2017. She previously worked in finance and brings her knowledge, skills and passion to the insurance world. For fun, she enjoys cooking gluten-free dishes, going to Lavallette Beach, watching movies with her niece and spending time with her dog, Huey. Stop by the agency and say hello to Angela!

Jake Mitchell

Licensed Sales Professional
Jake is from Gainesville, Florida and moved to Toms River in 2018. He’s embraced life in New Jersey through his volunteerism with Special Olympics New Jersey and the Community FoodBank of New Jersey. He graduated from the University of Central Florida in 2012 with a degree in hospitality management. He believes in excellent customer service and encourages a hospitable work environment. Outside of work, he spends time with his wife and their rescue pets and roots for Chicago sports teams.

Deena Brandmahl

Licensed Sales Professional
Deena graduated from High School East in Toms River and from Brick Computer SCI Institute. She excels at customer service and assisting customers however she can. She’s been with our agency since 2003. Prior to working for us, Deena worked for three other insurance agencies. She’s been a resident of Forked River for many years. In her spare time, Deena enjoys helping the Lacey Soccer Club, spending time with family, boating and crabbing.

Kyle Grieshaber

Licensed Sales Professional
Kyle, a graduate of Temple University, started his career in the insurance industry after working in finance. When not providing customers with information about Allstate products and services, he's a big sports fan (Go Mets! Go Giants!) who also enjoys camping and fishing.

Jayne Parmley

Licensed Sales Professional
Jayne is a graduate of the Stuart School of Business Administration and has been with the agency since the early 2000s. Before joining our team, she worked as a mortgage processor, where she gained valuable experience. Her primary focus is customer service, including our claim follow-up program. Jayne is a life-long Lacey resident. When not at work, she enjoys reading and crocheting. She also has a passion for puppies, working to raise seven dogs for the Seeing Eye, a guide dog school.

Patti Tutalo

Licensed Sales Professional
Patti is a graduate of Lacey Township High School. From there, she went on to the Atlantic School of Insurance. Patti joined our team in 2007. She enjoys assisting customers with getting their questions answered and helping them learn how to protect what they love most – assets, car, home and more. Patti has lived in Forked River her entire life. During her time away from the office, she enjoys spending time with her family, photography, camping and other outdoor activities.

George Johnson

Licensed Sales Professional
A life-long resident of Lanoka Harbor, George graduated from Kean University with a bachelor’s degree in public administration. He’s been around the insurance industry for many years and comes from a long line of family members with insurance industry experience. His responsibilities include responding to customer reviews, discussing coverage and relationship building. George enjoys the outdoors, skiing, running and kayaking, along with reading about and studying history during his spare time.

Doreen Dittfield

Licensed Sales Professional
Doreen is a life-long New Jersey resident. A graduate of Bergen Community College, she joined Considine Sharer & Associates with 30 years of industry experience. When not at work, she enjoys being outdoors, decorating and hosting gatherings, as well as being an active fundraiser for the Leslie Simon Breast Care and Cytodiagnosis Center. She’s also a certified volunteer with the “Look Good, Feel Better” program put on by the American Cancer Society.

Dimitri Tsougas

Licensed Sales Professional
Dimitri is a graduate of Rider University with a bachelor’s degree in business management and marketing. He brings a wealth of insurance industry knowledge to the team. A native of New Jersey, Dimitri lives in Mount Laurel Township. His primary responsibility is helping you learn how to protect yourself against life’s uncertainties. A true automobile aficionado, he can discuss any aspect of motor sports engineering with passion.

Patrick Matlock

Personal Financial Representative
Our Allstate Personal Financial Representative, Patrick, is available to help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals. From your child's education to your retirement, he can assist you with financial products that can help you build your financial future. Outside of work, Patrick enjoys boating, visiting museums and volunteering with Habitat for Humanity.

Recent reviews

Loading reviews...
No reviews available for this agent.

Local events & news

Get Free Disaster Prep Kit on July 13

When it comes to a disaster, we want to help you prepare for the unexpected! That’s why we’ll be at Asbury Park on July 13, along with the American Red Cross New Jersey Region, to help you assemble a free disaster preparedness kit. The Atlantic hurricane season is under way, and we want to help you be ready. On hand to broadcast live from the beach will be 107.1 The Boss.

Disaster Preparedness Event at Seaside Heights

We know that the best time to prepare for a disaster is well before it happens! That’s why we’re proud to have partnered with the American Red Cross to bring disaster preparedness awareness to our communities last week. We enjoyed meeting everyone who came out to the Seaside Heights Boardwalk to assemble their free disaster prep kit.

Does Car Insurance Cover Test Drives?

Have you ever wondered what would happen if you got into an accident during a test drive? Typically, the dealership or private owner's insurance would help cover the costs of the damage. Your policy would also most likely provide coverage for a non-owned car, so you'd typically have some coverage should a test drive not go particularly smoothly. Even though you'd most likely be covered, here are a few things you may want to consider before you test drive a new or used car.
Donn Sharer presents Agency Hands in the Community check to Millstone Township Foundation for Educational Excellance representative Nicole Pyhel.

We Support New Horizons In Autism!

We are proud to have assisted New Horizons in Autism by volunteering at their golf invitational. Because we support the cause of the organization, we helped them to also qualify for a $20,000 Allstate Foundation Helping Hands in the Community grant. The grant will help them to support individuals who suffer with autism. We look forward to working with New Horizons in Autism again!

Agent Donn Sharer volunteers with Achilles International, a non-profit, that provides athletes with disabilities with a community of support.

Agent Donn Sharer practices tandem bike riding with a triathlete. During Achilles Triathlon Camp, able-bodied volunteers and disabled athletes came together to train in an environment of support and community.

Bundle & save on insurance

Auto Insurance

Protecting what you love can be practical, too. With Allstate, you'll save when you purchase auto insurance along with another product. Your agent can help you maximize your savings and decide if bundling is right for you.

Be Ready For Whatever the Road May Bring.

From fixing a flat to getting a jump, Allstate offers several roadside assistance plans to help get you back on the road. Let’s find the roadside product that best suits your needs and your budget.
Learn MorePromotion Details
Referral Rewards: The referred customer must purchase an auto policy with Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Co. Under extremely rare circumstances the actual credit may be less than $75. These circumstances include instances where the premium charged is less than the credit amount. Maximum of three rewards can be banked at a time. Other rules and conditions apply.

Donn Sharer is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and South Carolina. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, or South Carolina, please go to the Find an Agent section on to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

Subject to terms, conditions & availability.

This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). Life insurance issued by Allstate Life Insurance Company: Northbrook, IL; and American Heritage Life Insurance Company: Jacksonville, FL. In New York, Allstate Life Insurance Company of New York: Hauppauge, NY. Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 2920 South 84th Street, Lincoln, NE 68506. (877) 525-5727.

Check the background of this firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck website.