Allstate Insurance Agent
Monica Titley, Sun Prairie, WI

1015 W Main St

Sun Prairie, WI 53590

Call

(608) 271-9900to quote by phone

Call

(608) 271-9900to quote by phone

Call

(608) 271-9900to quote by phone

Call

(608) 271-9900to quote by phone

Select a product to get a quote

ATV insurance

Location Details

Office Hours

Day of the Week	Hours
Mon	Available by appointment8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tue	Available by appointment8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed	Available by appointment8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thu	Available by appointment8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri	Available by appointment8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat	Available by appointment
Sun	Available by appointment

After-hours appointments available.

Available 24/7 at

(608) 271-9900

1015 W Main St
Sun Prairie, WI 53590
US

Landmarks

Our insurance agency is conveniently located on Main Street across the street from the strip mall next to St Vincents.

Areas Served

Sun Prairie, DeForest, Madison, Waunakee, Beaver Dam, Columbus, McFarland, Cottage Grove, Oregon, Monona, Stoughton, Watertown, Lodi, Sauk City, Fitchburg

Additional Contact

Fax: (833) 351-2866

Languages

English

Social

Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance

You can view my financial industry experience and background at FINRA’s BrokerCheck

Local Allstate Insurance Agent: Monica Titley

Allstate is passionate about domestic abuse awareness. We were able to visit a mural in Chicago done to raise awareness for our Purple Purse initiative.

Allstate sponsors annual Paint-a-thon with Project Home. Agent, Monica Titley, volunteered with group to paint a deserving community member’s house. What a difference we made in this woman’s life! Making a difference one day at a time.

It was an honor to represent Allstate at our Nations Capital visiting local representatives on the importance on the laws assisting women in domestic abuse situations.

Tim, Lindsay, and Monica Titley serving dinner at the Sunshine Supper in Sun Prairie.

Cutting the ribbon for our Grand Opening in 2014!

Monica Titley receives Sun Prairie Optimist award.

This little girl got her first life insurance policy. She is definitely in Good Hands now.

Allstate Catastrophe Team showing our equipment and how we handle the events that happen all across the country.

Recycle Rides and Allstate team up to give a new car to a very deserving single mom!

Delivering the donation of Reach A Child bags to the Sun Prairie First Responders.

Monica receives another award from the Sun Prairie Optimist Club.

$1,000 grant presented to Reach-A-Child and the Sun Prairie Fire Department

On Friday, September 8th, Allstate Insurance Agent: Monica Titley joined us for a REACH BAG refill to the Sun Prairie EMS Department.

MSG 2 Teen Winners!

Monica Titley had the pleasure of sponsoring and participating in the annual walk for Down Syndrome Awareness of Wisconsin.

We’re more than just an insurance agency — we’re your guide in protecting what matters most.

With over a decade of experience, our team has proudly helped individuals and families find insurance solutions that bring peace of mind and security. We understand that every customer is different, which is why we take a personalized approach to coverage — helping tailor policies to fit your unique needs, goals, and lifestyle.

Whether you're looking to protect your home, vehicle, or loved ones, Allstate offers a full range of coverage options including home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, condo insurance, boat insurance, motorcycle insurance, and life insurance.

What truly sets us apart is our commitment to exceptional service. We believe in long-term relationships built on trust, transparency, and a deep understanding of what matters most to you. Our team stays ahead of industry trends and changes so we can offer you informed choices and dependable guidance.

We’re passionate about people — not just policies. Helping you protect what you’ve worked hard for isn’t just our job; it’s our mission.

Wherever you are in your insurance journey, we’re here to help you protect what matters most — together.

Products we offer:

Car Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Car Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Helps protect you and your vehicle if you’re involved in a car accident. At a minimum, you’ll likely need bodily injury liability and property damage liability to meet state auto insurance coverage requirements and help protect your finances if you cause an accident that injures another driver or damages their property. We also offer uninsured motorist coverage to help with your expenses if you’re hit by a driver without insurance. If you’re looking for coverage to help protect your vehicle, you might want to consider collision coverage and comprehensive coverage, which help pay repair costs if your car is damaged in a covered loss. And, optional coverages, like new car replacement coverage or loan/lease gap coverage help protect your investment in a brand-new car. I can help you choose a combination of coverages that fulfill state requirements and meet your needs. Give me a call to get a car insurance quote today!
get a quote
Home Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Home Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Helps provide protection for your house (dwelling) and your family’s liability as well as the things you own in and around your home such as “other structures” (detached garage, fence, etc.), your personal property (furniture, clothing, etc.) against covered perils such as fire, theft, wind/hail and more. Call me today for a homeowners insurance quote and I’ll help you get the protection your home needs and the savings you deserve with our money-saving discounts.
get a quote
Condo Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Condo Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Helps protect the portion of your condo, co-op or townhome for which you are responsible for (inside structure, permanent fixtures, cabinets, etc.) with dependable coverage. Condo policies are HO-6 compliant, and cover family liability and personal belongings against covered perils such as fire, theft, vandalism and more. Contact me today for a quote!
get a quote
Renters Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Renters Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Helps protect your personal belongings inside or outside your apartment from accidents such as, fire, theft, vandalism, and cover family liability. Give me call today to review what type of coverage makes sense for where you live and what you own.
get a quote
Motorcycle Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Motorcycle Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Our motorcycle policies include the basic coverage you may need, like liability coverage, which includes passenger liability coverage and uninsured motorist coverage. You can further customize your motorcycle policy with collision coverage and comprehensive coverage to help protect your bike. And, if you have a customized ride, you can help protect your aftermarket gear with optional equipment coverage. Contact me to learn about motorcycle insurance discounts and to get started with a quote for a policy that fits your needs.
get a quote
Business Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Business Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Allstate Business Insurance protects your business in ways other insurance might not. A business owners policy (BOP) usually includes three common types of coverage to help protect you and your small business: property coverage, general liability coverage and business interruption coverage. In addition to these basic coverages, the Allstate Business Owners Policy can be customized with additional protection to help cover more aspects of your business. I can help you tailor a policy to fit your small business’s needs. As a small business owner myself, I understand how important it is to protect what you’ve worked so hard to build. Call me for a free review of your current business policy and to learn more about insurance solutions to help protect you, your business and your employees.
Life Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Life Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Protect the life you want, for those that matter most. A life insurance policy can help provide financial security for your loved ones by covering expenses like the mortgage, college tuition, and other everyday living costs. Call me today to learn about the different types of coverage Allstate offers.
ATV Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
ATV Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Help protect yourself and your all-terrain vehicle against the unexpected. We offer bodily injury liability coverage and property damage liability coverage on your ATV insurance policy. If you injure someone else or damage their property while driving your ATV, liability coverage helps pay the other person’s medical or repair bills. If your ATV is damaged in a crash, collision coverage may help. Collision coverage for your ATV helps pay for repairs if you hit another object, such as a fence or a tree. Finally, you may want to consider comprehensive coverage for your ATV in case it’s stolen, vandalized or damaged by hail or fire. Give me a call to get a quote on an ATV insurance policy today!
get a quote
Boat Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Boat Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie
Helps cover your boat on and off the water. Watercraft liability coverage helps pay for another person’s expenses if you injure them or damage their property with your boat. If you’re injured in a boating accident, watercraft medical payments coverage helps pay for your medical bills. Need to repair damage to your boat after an accident? Property coverage for your boat helps cover a crash with another boat or object (like a pier or buoy). It also helps cover theft, vandalism or fire. Help protect your boat against these covered perils during the on- and off-season. We also offer additional coverage for things like your boat trailer, fishing equipment and even towing or fuel delivery when you’re stranded. Need a boat insurance quote? Give me a call today!

10+

Years of
Experience

10+

Years in the
Community

Your Local Allstate Team

Danielle Henning

Licensed Office Manager

Danielle has been in the community since 2019, and we were excited to welcome her to our team that same year. As a Licensed Office Manager, Danielle takes great pride in welcoming people that come to visit us at our agency and helping people with their questions for insurance. When she is not in the agency, Danielle enjoys making memories with her young son. Call our agency and Danielle would be happy to assist you with your auto insurance, home insurance, and the other services.

Ashley Wilkerson

Customer Care Professional

Ashley has been in the area since 2016, and we were excited to welcome her to our team in 2017. Ashley is our Office Manager and she oversees our daily operations. As a proud mother of two children, Ashley welcomes the opportunity to meet and assist other families with their unique insurance needs. When she’s not in the office, Ashley enjoys working on her photography and playing board games with her kids. Call our agency to see how Ashley can assist you.

Monica Titley

Agency Owner - Personal Financial Representative

Entering the insurance industry in 2014, Monica Titley quickly became a standout professional driven by a genuine desire to help protect and assist customers. Not content with merely working in the field, Monica took the initiative to establish Titley Insurance Group, a testament to her entrepreneurial spirit and commitment to providing comprehensive coverage.

As the founder of the agency, Monica oversees the sales of insurance lines, with a particular focus on Retirement insurance. Her dedication to offering a broad spectrum of coverage choices showcases her commitment to addressing the diverse needs of customers, helping them get well-protected against the uncertainties of life.

Monica's favorite aspect of her role lies in the personal connection she forges with customers. Driven by a mission to make a positive impact, she works diligently to help customers have the coverage they need for unforeseen mishaps. Monica believes that, if done correctly, her efforts can transform what could be a very bad day for a customer into a manageable situation with the right coverage in place.

Outside of work, Monica's life is enriched by her role as a mother to two daughters, born just 10.5 months apart. Their shared love for sports keeps her actively engaged in their pursuits, adding a joyful dimension to her family life.

Beyond her immediate circle, Monica's biggest passion lies in helping people. Volunteering and giving back to the community are integral parts of her life, reflecting her commitment to making a positive impact beyond the realm of insurance. Monica Titley is not just a leader in the insurance industry; she is a compassionate individual dedicated to the well-being of customers and the community she serves.

Tammy Swikert

Licensed Manager

Tammy Swikert is a dedicated Property, Casualty, and more insurance agent with a robust background in financial protection and customer support. She brings years of experience navigating complex insurance landscapes, including previous roles in health and other insurance and as a senior claims analyst. Whether she is providing a small act of kindness or helping see a family is fully protected against unforeseen loss, her technical precision in data entry and research is matched only by her genuine passion for helping others.

When she is not in the office, Tammy is an outdoor enthusiast who enjoys riding her motorcycle and reading. Above all, she is a devoted mother of four children and a proud "Nana" to two amazing grandsons who keep her inspired and motivated every day.

Darin Kath

Licensed Manager

Darin Kath brings a wealth of seasoned insurance experience to our team, having dedicated many years to mastering virtually every aspect of the industry. Today, his absolute favorite part of the job is working directly on the front lines and truly helping customers secure the peace of mind they deserve. His deep, well-rounded knowledge allows him to help customers through complex decisions with a genuinely supportive hand. When he isn't taking exceptional care of customers, Darin loves nothing more than relaxing and enjoying quality time with his wife and their dog, Leo.

Allstate Insurance Agent Reviews

leonard bruflat

Jun. 1, 2026

Monica was very helpful with advice for the best coverages to fit our needs. Appreciate her time and patience. Thanks

mary browning

May. 31, 2026

Ok, nothing special but nothing bad

gale lembcke

May. 27, 2026

denise thomas

May. 23, 2026

Very good service, very good rates.

edgar pastrana rugama

May. 15, 2026

Agent Response

Edgar, thank you for taking the time to leave us a

Edgar, thank you for taking the time to leave us a 4-star review! We truly appreciate your trust in our insurance agency and are glad you had a positive experience overall. Our team is always striving to provide 5-star insurance service, so if there’s ever anything we can do to earn that extra star, we’d love the opportunity to help. Please feel free to call us anytime at 608-234-4300.

ronald humphrey

May. 12, 2026

Agent Response

Ronald, thank you for the 5-star rating! It means

Ronald, thank you for the 5-star rating! It means a great deal to our team that you chose our insurance agency and had a positive experience with us. We’re committed to providing dependable service and guidance you can count on. Whenever you need help with your insurance or have questions about your coverage, our office is always available at 608-234-4300.

james krause

May. 7, 2026

Lower the price to make me feel happy

Agent Response

James, thank you for the 5-star review! We truly a

James, thank you for the 5-star review! We truly appreciate your sense of humor and your continued trust in our insurance agency. We’re always happy to review coverage, discounts, and policy options to help make sure you’re getting the best value possible. If you’d ever like us to take another look at your insurance, give our team a call anytime at 608-234-4300 — we’re always here to help!

michael hauser

Apr. 5, 2026

Very easy to work with Danielle.

Agent Response

Michael, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re

Michael, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re so glad to hear Danielle made the insurance process easy and enjoyable for you. Providing simple, helpful service is exactly what we aim for, and we appreciate you recognizing her. If you ever need anything with your insurance, our team is always available at 608-234-4300.

dennis andino

Mar. 31, 2026

Comfortable and went fine

Agent Response

Dennis, we truly appreciate your 5-star review! It

Dennis, we truly appreciate your 5-star review! It’s great to hear everything went well and that the process felt comfortable from start to finish. Our insurance team works hard to make each experience clear, smooth, and easy to navigate. Whenever you need assistance, you can always reach us at 608-234-4300.

robert robinson

Mar. 29, 2026

Agent Response

Robert, thank you for taking the time to leave a r

Robert, thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We’re sorry to see your experience did not meet expectations. Providing dependable service and support with your insurance is important to our agency, and feedback like this helps us improve. A member of our team will be reaching out to learn more about your experience and see how we can better assist moving forward.

william stahl

Mar. 19, 2026

You said one question

Agent Response

William, thank you for the 5-star rating and the p

William, thank you for the 5-star rating and the perfect score! We're glad we could keep things simple and efficient for you—even if it took more than just "one question" to get everything perfect. Providing streamlined, dependable service for your insurance needs is what we strive for every day at our Sun Prairie Allstate office. Whether it's auto, home, or life insurance, our goal is to make the process as clear and easy as possible.. We appreciate you choosing us and are happy to hear you're satisfied with our team. If you ever have another question (or three!), please feel free to call us at 608-234-4300—we are always here to help. Thanks again, Monica Titley

sharon kane

Mar. 13, 2026

I am thoroughly impressed with Monica Turkey and the employees at the Sun Prairie, WI office. She was generous with her

I am thoroughly impressed with Monica Turkey and the employees at the Sun Prairie, WI office. She was generous with her time and showed me ways to save money and improve my coverage. I highly recommend her.

Agent Response

Sharon, thank you so much for the 5-star review an

Sharon, thank you so much for the 5-star review and the kind recommendation! We are thrilled to hear you were impressed with our service and that our team could help you find ways to save while improving your coverage. At our Sun Prairie Allstate office, we take pride in taking the time to ensure every client feels confident and protected. Whether it's auto, home, or life insurance, our goal is to provide dependable service for our clients. We truly appreciate your support! If you ever need anything else, please feel free to call us at 608-234-4300—we are always here to help. Thanks again, Monica Titley, 608-234-4300

stacie russell

Mar. 12, 2026

Agent Response

Stacie, thank you for the 4-star rating! We truly

Stacie, thank you for the 4-star rating! We truly appreciate you choosing our Sun Prairie Allstate office for your insurance needs. Our goal is always to provide a 5-star experience, so if there is anything we can do to earn that extra star from you next time, please let us know. Whether you have questions about your auto, home, or life insurance, we are here to provide the best service possible. If you need anything at all, please feel free to call us at 608-234-4300—we are always here to help. Thanks again, Monica Titley, 608-234-4300

jeffrey frye

Mar. 3, 2026

Easy to reach knowledgeable and attentive to my needs. Thank you

Agent Response

Jeffrey, thank you for the 5-star review and for s

Jeffrey, thank you for the 5-star review and for sharing your experience! We’re glad to hear our team has been easy to reach and able to provide the knowledgeable insurance service you deserve. Being attentive to our customers’ insurance needs is always our priority. If there’s ever anything you’d like to review or any questions come up, feel free to contact our office at 608-234-4300 — we’re always here to help.

karen capps

Mar. 2, 2026

Agent Response

Karen, we truly appreciate the 5-star rating—tha

Karen, we truly appreciate the 5-star rating—thank you for taking the time to support our insurance agency! It’s always rewarding to know our team is delivering the kind of service our clients deserve. Whether you need help reviewing your insurance coverage or have a quick question, our office is always available. You can reach us anytime at 608-234-4300, and we’ll be glad to assist.

timothy tantillo

Mar. 2, 2026

Always Great" I Ramble' on Sometimes ' N we Laugh" I Feel Thats ' What makes a company is " The ones That work for you""

Always Great" I Ramble' on Sometimes ' N we Laugh" I Feel Thats ' What makes a company is " The ones That work for you"" I Have Recommended ' You ' And Will Continue Doing. THANK'S For Puttin' Up With me.Tim.😁

Agent Response

Tim, thank you for the fantastic 5-star review! We

Tim, thank you for the fantastic 5-star review! We truly enjoy working with you and appreciate the laughs along the way. Building real relationships with the people we help is one of the best parts of being in the insurance business, and it means a lot that you’ve recommended our agency to others. Thanks for your continued trust and support! If you ever need anything related to your insurance, you can always reach our team at 608-234-4300.

larry wheeler

Mar. 2, 2026

No real experience, hardly any contact since taking over for Jim Fish, not the same service

Agent Response

Larry, thank you for taking the time to leave a re

Larry, thank you for taking the time to leave a review and share your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your experience hasn’t felt the same as it did in the past. We understand how important consistent service is when it comes to your insurance, and we truly appreciate you sharing your concerns with us.

Our agency only began servicing your insurance policies last year, but we absolutely want to make sure you receive the level of communication and support you expect. A member of our team will be reaching out to you soon so we can connect, review your coverage, and make sure all of your insurance needs are being taken care of.

In the meantime, please feel free to contact our office directly at 608-234-4300 if there’s anything you’d like to discuss sooner. We appreciate the opportunity to serve you and hope to earn your confidence moving forward.

walter pergande

Feb. 28, 2026

Agent Response

Walter, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re g

Walter, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re grateful you chose our agency for your insurance and appreciate you taking the time to leave a rating. Our goal is to make insurance straightforward and dependable for every customer we serve. If you ever want to review your coverage or have a question about your insurance, feel free to reach out to our team at 608-234-4300 — we’re always glad to assist.

fredrick lauper

Feb. 24, 2026

Disappointing

Agent Response

Fredrick, thank you for taking the time to leave a

Fredrick, thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We’re sorry to hear that your experience with our insurance agency was disappointing. That’s certainly not the experience we want any of our customers to have.

We would really appreciate the opportunity to learn more about what happened and see how we can help make things right. A member of our team will be reaching out to you to better understand your concerns and review your insurance needs. You’re also welcome to contact our office directly at 608-234-4300 at your convenience. We value your feedback and hope to improve your experience moving forward.

philip obrien

Feb. 23, 2026

Agent Response

Philip, thank you so much for speaking with us and

Philip, thank you so much for speaking with us and clarifying that the 0.5-star rating was an accidental error! We truly appreciate you confirming that you intended to give us a 5-star review for the service you've received at our Sun Prairie Allstate office. Providing dependable coverage for your auto, home, or life insurance is our top priority, and we’re glad to know you're happy with our team. If you ever have any questions or need further assistance with your policies, please feel free to call us at 608-234-4300—we are always here to help. Thanks again, Monica Titley, 608-234-4300

Allstate Online Review Policy

Your Local Allstate Team

Danielle Henning

Licensed Office Manager

Ashley Wilkerson

Customer Care Professional

Monica Titley

Agency Owner - Personal Financial Representative

Tammy Swikert

Licensed Manager

Darin Kath

Licensed Manager

Frequently asked questions

What are your agency hours?

Monday: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday:
Sunday:

Are you open on weekends?

Saturday:
Sunday:

Can I text your agency with questions?

Yes, we have text messaging services.

What languages do you speak?

We have staff members available who speak the following languages: English

Do you have more than one location?

No, this is our only location.

Monica Titley is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Illinois and Wisconsin. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Illinois or Wisconsin, please go to the Find an Agent section on allstate.com to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

Based on coverages selected. Subject to terms, conditions, availability & qualifications.

This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate North American Insurance Co. and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). This life insurance information is provided for general consumer educational purposes and is not intended to provide legal, tax or investment advice. Life insurance also offered and issued by third party companies not affiliated with Allstate. Each company is solely responsible for the financial obligations accruing under the products it issues. Product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing company.

Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 151 North 8th Street, Suite 450, Lincoln, NE 68508. (877) 232-2142.

Check the background of this firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck website.

you're in good hands^®