Allstate Insurance Agency
Simonelli Agency Llc, East Setauket, NY

100 S Jersey Ave,

Unit 25

East Setauket, NY 11733

Call

(631) 689-3100to quote by phone

Call

(631) 689-3100to quote by phone

Call

(631) 689-3100to quote by phone

Call

(631) 689-3100to quote by phone

Select a product to get a quote

Motorcycle insurance

ATV insurance

Location Details

Office Hours

Day of the Week	Hours
Mon	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tue	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thu	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat	Available by appointment
Sun	Closed

After-hours appointments available.

Available 24/7 at

(631) 689-3100

100 S Jersey Ave,
Unit 25
East Setauket, NY 11733
US

Map of 100 S Jersey Ave in East Setauket

Landmarks

1 mile east of SUNY Stony brook off 25A in back of the Wild by Nature Shopping Center

Areas Served

East Setauket

Languages

English, Spanish

Simonelli Agency Llc: Allstate Insurance

Local Allstate Agency: Meet Simonelli Agency Llc

I’ve gotten to know many local families as an Allstate agent in East Setauket. I enjoy being a part of the community, and building local relationships is one of the best parts of my job. I know what life is like here in East Setauket – that you choose your car and your home to fit your lifestyle and your budget. I also know how important it is to do the same when it comes to insurance. I look forward to getting to know you and helping you to find the solutions that meet your needs.

Part of what I like best about my job is that I can offer customers options for a wide variety of coverage and services. You can depend on me to help you look at the big picture.

I’m committed to helping East Setauket residents assess their immediate and long-term needs and choose options that will help them achieve their goals. When you want to explore options for protecting your home, personal property, or financial future, I’m available to answer your questions. If you’re already a customer, I’m ready to review your coverage so that you can make any necessary adjustments to fit your changing needs. Call me today.

Part of what I like best about my job is that I can offer customers options for a wide variety of coverage and services. You can depend on me to help you look at the big picture.

Products we offer:

Car Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Car Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps protect you and your vehicle if you’re involved in a car accident. At a minimum, you’ll likely need bodily injury liability and property damage liability to meet state auto insurance coverage requirements and help protect your finances if you cause an accident that injures another driver or damages their property. We also offer uninsured motorist coverage to help with your expenses if you’re hit by a driver without insurance. If you’re looking for coverage to help protect your vehicle, you might want to consider collision coverage and comprehensive coverage, which help pay repair costs if your car is damaged in a covered loss. And, optional coverages, like new car replacement coverage or loan/lease gap coverage help protect your investment in a brand-new car. I can help you choose a combination of coverages that fulfill state requirements and meet your needs. Give me a call to get a car insurance quote today!
get a quote
Home Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Home Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps provide protection for your house (dwelling) and your family’s liability as well as the things you own in and around your home such as “other structures” (detached garage, fence, etc.), your personal property (furniture, clothing, etc.) against covered perils such as fire, theft, wind/hail and more. Call me today for a homeowners insurance quote and I’ll help you get the protection your home needs and the savings you deserve with our money-saving discounts.
get a quote
Condo Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Condo Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps protect the portion of your condo, co-op or townhome for which you are responsible for (inside structure, permanent fixtures, cabinets, etc.) with dependable coverage. Condo policies are HO-6 compliant, and cover family liability and personal belongings against covered perils such as fire, theft, vandalism and more. Contact me today for a quote!
get a quote
Renters Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Renters Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps protect your personal belongings inside or outside your apartment from accidents such as, fire, theft, vandalism, and cover family liability. Give me call today to review what type of coverage makes sense for where you live and what you own.
get a quote
Landlords & Hosts Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Landlords & Hosts Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps protect the structure of your rental property, from covered accidents such as fire, wind/hail, vandalism and more. It also offers protection for the liability you might face as an owner. Let’s chat about the right coverage for your additional property!
Motorcycle Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Motorcycle Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Our motorcycle policies include the basic coverage you may need, like liability coverage, which includes passenger liability coverage and uninsured motorist coverage. You can further customize your motorcycle policy with collision coverage and comprehensive coverage to help protect your bike. And, if you have a customized ride, you can help protect your aftermarket gear with optional equipment coverage. Contact me to learn about motorcycle insurance discounts and to get started with a quote for a policy that fits your needs.
get a quote
Business Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Business Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Allstate Business Insurance protects your business in ways other insurance might not. A business owners policy (BOP) usually includes three common types of coverage to help protect you and your small business: property coverage, general liability coverage and business interruption coverage. In addition to these basic coverages, the Allstate Business Owners Policy can be customized with additional protection to help cover more aspects of your business. I can help you tailor a policy to fit your small business’s needs. As a small business owner myself, I understand how important it is to protect what you’ve worked so hard to build. Call me for a free review of your current business policy and to learn more about insurance solutions to help protect you, your business and your employees.
Life Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Life Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Protect the life you want, for those that matter most. A life insurance policy can help provide financial security for your loved ones by covering expenses like the mortgage, college tuition, and other everyday living costs. Call me today to learn about the different types of coverage Allstate offers.
ATV Insurance Agent in East Setauket
ATV Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Help protect yourself and your all-terrain vehicle against the unexpected. We offer bodily injury liability coverage and property damage liability coverage on your ATV insurance policy. If you injure someone else or damage their property while driving your ATV, liability coverage helps pay the other person’s medical or repair bills. If your ATV is damaged in a crash, collision coverage may help. Collision coverage for your ATV helps pay for repairs if you hit another object, such as a fence or a tree. Finally, you may want to consider comprehensive coverage for your ATV in case it’s stolen, vandalized or damaged by hail or fire. Give me a call to get a quote on an ATV insurance policy today!
get a quote
Boat Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Boat Insurance Agent in East Setauket
Helps cover your boat on and off the water. Watercraft liability coverage helps pay for another person’s expenses if you injure them or damage their property with your boat. If you’re injured in a boating accident, watercraft medical payments coverage helps pay for your medical bills. Need to repair damage to your boat after an accident? Property coverage for your boat helps cover a crash with another boat or object (like a pier or buoy). It also helps cover theft, vandalism or fire. Help protect your boat against these covered perils during the on- and off-season. We also offer additional coverage for things like your boat trailer, fishing equipment and even towing or fuel delivery when you’re stranded. Need a boat insurance quote? Give me a call today!

Your Local Allstate Team

John Simonelli

Agency Owner

Welcome to An Allstate Agency
Led by John Simonelli, Agency Owner

At our agency, we do more than provide insurance—we help build relationships, offer peace of mind, and protect the people and things you value most.

As the Agency Owner, I’m proud to lead a team of licensed professionals who are passionate about serving our community with integrity, knowledge, and heart. With the trusted backing of Allstate, we deliver personalized coverage for auto, home, life, and business needs—helping see customers walks away informed, protected, and confident.

Our Mission

To help families, individuals, and businesses safeguard their futures while delivering exceptional service, tailored solutions, and a truly local experience.

Why Choose Us?

✅ Local knowledge, national strength
✅ 100% commitment to customer care
✅ Claims support and regular policy reviews
✅ Community-driven and proudly \[City]-based

Whether you're insuring your first car, your family’s forever home, or your growing business, we’re here to make the process smooth, personal, and empowering.

Let us help you protect what matters most.

Andrea Postiglione

Office Manager

As your local Allstate agent and office manager since 2022, I’m proud to serve our community by helping families protect what matters most. I’m passionate about building strong relationships with customers and helping them feel confident about their coverage.

Outside of the office, I enjoy spending time with my wonderful husband, Lenny, and our three amazing daughters—Charlotte, Penny, and Magnolia. Together, we love making memories, whether it’s enjoying the outdoors or spending cozy family nights at home.

I’m here to help you with personalized insurance solutions and exceptional service. Feel free to stop by the office or give us a call—I look forward to working with you!

Amanda Regan

Production Manager

With over a decade of experience in the office since joining in 2009, I began my career working alongside my parents, Jeff and Darlene, who first brought me onto the team. I am a licensed sales professional specializing in Property & Casualty and Life insurance, committed to helping individuals and families protect what matters most.

One of the most rewarding aspects of my role is building genuine relationships with customer. I take pride in getting to know people on a personal level and serving as a trusted, reliable resource in their lives.

Outside of the office, my husband and I have two children, Chloe and Jack. Our family enjoys spending time at the beach and creating memorable times together. On most weekends, you’ll find me cheering from the sidelines at a soccer or baseball field.

Alyssa Ciccariello

Licensed Sales Agent/Onboarding Specialist

Hi, I’m Alyss. an insurance agent representing Allstate focused on helping people protect what matters most—without making the process feel overwhelming. I work with individuals, families, and small business owners to find coverage that fits their needs, whether it’s auto, home, or business insurance.
My approach is straightforward and customers-first: I take the time to describe options clearly, answer questions, and help see you feel confident in the decisions you’re making. I believe insurance should be simple, transparent, and tailored to your life—not a one-size-fits-all solution.
Outside of work, I spend a lot of time with my 5-month-old bulldog, Simba, who keeps me busy and always reminds me to enjoy the little things.
I’m proud to represent Allstate and to be a trusted resource for customers, helping them stay protected today and prepared for the future.

Allstate Insurance Agent Reviews

james kuttiyara

May. 27, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, James, for your positive feedback and f

Thank you, James, for your positive feedback and for being a valued customer. We're glad to hear you're satisfied with our services. If you have any further questions or need assistance, please feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com. Your trust means a lot to us!

saul goodhart

May. 16, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Saul, for your positive feedback and fo

Thank you, Saul, for your positive feedback and for being a valued customer. We're glad to hear you're satisfied with our services. If you have any further questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com.

heidi jones

Apr. 6, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Heidi, for your wonderful feedback! We'

Thank you, Heidi, for your wonderful feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you had a positive experience with us. Your trust and satisfaction are our top priorities. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out. We appreciate your support!

edward pozzi

Mar. 25, 2026

Good as usual

Agent Response

Thank you, Edward, for your continued trust and su

Thank you, Edward, for your continued trust and support. We're thrilled to hear that your experience with us remains positive. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out.

robert potter

Mar. 22, 2026

Drivewise should only show locations while driving, not all the time,that would be too invasive.

Agent Response

Thank you, Robert, for your feedback on Drivewise.

Thank you, Robert, for your feedback on Drivewise. We understand your concern about privacy and appreciate your input. Your insights help us improve our services. If you have any more suggestions or questions, feel free to reach out.

madhuri ramnath

Mar. 11, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Madhuri, for your positive feedback! We

Thank you, Madhuri, for your positive feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you had a great experience with us. Your trust and satisfaction are our top priorities. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out. We appreciate your support!

barry zang

Mar. 5, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you for your feedback, Barry. We're glad to

Thank you for your feedback, Barry. We're glad to hear you had a positive experience with us. If you have any suggestions for improvement or further concerns, please feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com. We appreciate your trust and look forward to serving you in the future.

marta molina perez

Mar. 5, 2026

Great!

Agent Response

Thank you, Marta, for your positive feedback! We'r

Thank you, Marta, for your positive feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you had a great experience with us. Your satisfaction is our priority, and we look forward to continuing to serve your insurance needs.

gerald freund

Feb. 26, 2026

My experience with Allstate has always been positive.

Agent Response

Thank you, Gerald, for sharing your positive exper

Thank you, Gerald, for sharing your positive experience with Allstate. We're thrilled to hear that you've had such a great experience with us. Your trust and satisfaction are our top priorities. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out.

mark fanara

Feb. 25, 2026

Agent Response

Hi Mark, thank you for sharing your feedback. I'm

Hi Mark, thank you for sharing your feedback. I'm sorry to hear about your experience. We value your input and would like to address your concerns. Please feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com so we can assist you further. We appreciate your time and hope to improve your experience with us.

yue zhang

Feb. 17, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Yue, for your positive feedback and for

Thank you, Yue, for your positive feedback and for being a valued customer. We're glad to hear you're satisfied with our services. If you have any suggestions for improvement, feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com. Your trust is important to us!

barry ortenberg

Feb. 16, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Barry, for your positive feedback and p

Thank you, Barry, for your positive feedback and perfect rating! We're thrilled to know you're satisfied with our services. As a valued customer, your trust means a lot to us. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out.

john barrotta

Feb. 15, 2026

Great service!

Agent Response

Thank you, John, for your kind words! We're thrill

Thank you, John, for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear that you had a great experience with our service. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we look forward to continuing to meet your insurance needs.

peter kohut

Feb. 13, 2026

Agent Response

Hi Peter, Thank you for sharing your feedback. W

Hi Peter,

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We understand your concerns and are here to help. Please feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com for further assistance. Your input is valuable to us, and we appreciate your time.

Best regards,
The Simonelli Agency Team

n telfeyan

Feb. 7, 2026

Excellent customer assistance always.

Agent Response

Thank you for your kind words! We're thrilled to h

Thank you for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear that you've consistently received excellent customer assistance. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we appreciate your trust in Simonelli Agency LLC: Allstate Insurance. If you ever need anything, feel free to reach out.

alfred julia

Jan. 31, 2026

I haven't had any experience working wit your agency directly. You are fairly new to me even though I've been with Allst

I haven't had any experience working wit your agency directly. You are fairly new to me even though I've been with Allstate for 4 years. I didn't know that it changed hands.

Agent Response

Thank you for sharing your experience, Alfred. We

Thank you for sharing your experience, Alfred. We appreciate your loyalty to Allstate over the past four years. If you have any questions or need assistance, please feel free to reach out. We're here to help!

william viola

Jan. 25, 2026

Not good, lousy phone skills, don't listen very well just one sided conversation

Agent Response

Hi William, I'm sorry to hear about your experienc

Hi William, I'm sorry to hear about your experience. We strive to provide attentive service and it's concerning to hear this feedback. Please reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com so we can address your concerns directly. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.

sharon murray

Jan. 6, 2026

Agent Response

Thank you, Sharon, for your positive feedback! We'

Thank you, Sharon, for your positive feedback! We're thrilled to know you're satisfied with our services. Your trust and support as a valued customer mean a lot to us. If you ever need assistance, feel free to reach out.

paul feinberg

Jan. 4, 2026

Amanda is very competent, and ell organized.

Agent Response

Thank you, Paul, for your kind words about Amanda.

Thank you, Paul, for your kind words about Amanda. We're thrilled to hear that her competence and organization have made a positive impact on your experience with us. Your feedback is greatly appreciated!

barbara connolly

Dec. 22, 2025

Agent Response

Thank you, Barbara, for your positive feedback and

Thank you, Barbara, for your positive feedback and for being a valued customer. We're glad to hear you're satisfied with our services. If you have any further questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to johnsimonelli@allstate.com. Your trust means a lot to us!

Allstate Online Review Policy