Allstate Insurance Agent

Andrew J. McCabe, Milwaukee, WI

4010 N Oakland Ave

Milwaukee, WI 53211

(414) 961-1166available 24/724/7

Select a Product to Get a Quote

Office Hours

Day of the Week	Hours
Mon	8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tue	8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed	8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thu	8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri	8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat	Available by appointment
Sun	Closed

After-hours appointments available.

Available 24/7 at

(414) 961-1166

4010 N Oakland Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53211
US

2442 S Kinnickinnic Ave

Milwaukee, WI 53207

7046 W Greenfield Ave

West Allis, WI 53214

Areas Served

Milwaukee, Shorewood, Whitefish Bay, Bay View, Wauwatosa, Glendale, West Allis, Greenfield, Brookfield

Landmarks

We are on the corner of Oakland Avenue and Capitol Drive in Shorewood across the street from Sendik's.

Additional Contact

Fax: (414) 961-1360

Toll Free: (866) 961-1166

Social

Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance

You can view my financial industry experience and background at FINRA’s BrokerCheck

Local Allstate Agent: Meet Andrew J. McCabe

View this video on YouTube

In 2004, I opened my first agency in Shorewood. I was drawn to Shorewood because of its small-town feel, thriving business district and proximity to downtown Milwaukee and Lake Michigan. I have lived in the community since opening my first office and I have come to know many families and businesses on the east side of Milwaukee. Throughout the years, my business has grown because of the people here. In the fall of 2013, I opened my second office in Bay View to better service customers on the south side of Milwaukee.

I enjoy giving back by coaching Whitefish Bay Little League, acting as vice president of the Shorewood Business Improvement District and sponsoring several Shorewood Recreation and Community Services events. I also enjoy competing in golf tournaments, hosting dinners for family and friends, visiting farmers markets or searching for sea glass with my children at Atwater Beach.

I understand the importance of being there for loved ones and investing in the future. My team is committed to providing individuals, families and small businesses with quality insurance options at an affordable rate. We can also help you achieve your long- and short-term financial goals, including preparing for your child’s education and your retirement. Our dedicated support continues throughout our entire relationship. We are here for you. Call us today!

Products we offer:

Auto
Home
Condo
Renters
Motorcycle
Business
Life
ATV
Boat

10+

Years of
Experience

10+

Years in the
Community

Our team

Jessica Kvapil

Licensed Sales Professional

Jessica started her insurance career with the McCabe Agency in 2012. Away from the office, Jessica enjoys watching her son play soccer for the Croatian Eagles Soccer Club and enjoys watching her daughter dance with the Glencastle Irish Dancers. During her free time Jessica enjoys relaxing and spending time with her friends and family outdoors or at the lake.

Connor Kelly

Licensed Sales Professional

Connor has worked in the insurance industry since 2012, and we were pleased to have him join our team in 2016. Connor enjoys spending his free time traveling, watching college sports and trying new restaurants and bars. You may al

Patrick McCabe

Licensed Sales Professional

Pat has been in the insurance industry since 1980. Pat is Andrew’s father and he specializes in assisting customers as they make their life insurance coverage decisions. He can also help you prepare for retirement. Outside of work, Pat volunteers with the USO of Wisconsin, works with the UW-Milwaukee men’s basketball program and spends time relaxing in Arizona

Doris Falkowski

Agency Manager - Shorewood

Doris has worked with Allstate since 2003 and the McCabe Agency in Shorewood since 2007. She likes to help make a difference in the Greater Milwaukee community and she is passionate about her work. Outside of the office, Doris enj

John Murphy

Licensed Sales Professional

Jessica Ziegler

Agency Manager

Terra Rummel

Licensed Sales Professional

Amy McCabe

Licensed Sales Professional

Arika Olson

Agency Manager

Hannah Krygiel

Agency Manager

Mike Kreitzer

Licensed Sales Professional

Bundle & save on insurance

Auto Insurance

Protecting what you love can be practical, too. With Allstate, you'll save when you purchase auto insurance along with another product. Your agent can help you maximize your savings and decide if bundling is right for you.
Get a Quote Learn More

Home Insurance

Protecting your home can save you money. When you purchase a home policy with at least one other Allstate policy, you'll unlock our bundling discount. Talk to your Allstate agent to learn how you can maximize your savings and best protect your home.
Get a Quote Learn More

Life Insurance

Protecting the people you love is your first priority. But, when you purchase a life insurance policy alongside another Allstate product, you can also save money. Talk to an agent for help deciding if bundling is right for you.
Learn More