Allstate Insurance Agent MATTHEW SMITHERMAN

Allstate Insurance Agent 
MATTHEW SMITHERMAN, Reynoldsburg, OH

Location pin icon
1607 Brice Rd
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
US
Call
(614) 367-0291to quote by phone
Call
(614) 367-0291to quote by phone
Call
(614) 367-0291to quote by phone
Call
(614) 367-0291to quote by phone
Select a product to get a quoteSelect a product to get a quote
Auto insurance
Home insurance
Condo insurance
Renters insurance
Motorcycle insurance
ATVATV
ATV insurance

Location Details

Office Hours

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
SatClosed
SunClosed
Available 24/7 at
(614) 367-0291
(614) 367-0291

1607 Brice Rd
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
US

Map of 1607 Brice Rd in Reynoldsburg

Landmarks

Conveniently located on Brice Rd. Just south of the Columbus Metropolitan Library

Areas Served

Proudly serving Reynoldsburg, New Albany, Pickerington, Blacklick, and the surrounding areas.

Languages

English
MATTHEW SMITHERMAN: Allstate Insurance
You can view my financial industry experience and background at FINRA’s BrokerCheck

Local Allstate Insurance Agent: MATTHEW SMITHERMAN

MATTHEW SMITHERMAN Reynoldsburg, OH
Photo gallery preview

It gives me tremendous pleasure to assume the reigns of our agency. I’ve gotten to know many local families as an Allstate agent in Reynoldsburg. I enjoy being a part of the community, and building local relationships is one of the best parts of my job. I know what life is like here in Reynoldsburg – that you choose your car and your home to fit your lifestyle and your budget. I also know how important it is to do the same when it comes to insurance. I look forward to getting to know you and helping you to find the solutions that meet your needs.


Part of what I like best about my job is that I can offer customers options for a wide variety of coverage and services. You can depend on me to help you look at the big picture.


I’m committed to helping Reynoldsburg residents assess their immediate and long-term needs and choose options that will help them achieve their goals. When you want to explore options for protecting your home, personal property, or financial future, I’m available to answer your questions. If you’re already a customer, I’m ready to review your coverage so that you can make any necessary adjustments to fit your changing needs. Call me today.

It gives me tremendous pleasure to assume the reigns of our agency. I’ve gotten to know many local families as an Allstate agent in Reynoldsburg. I enjoy being a part of the community, and building local relationships is one of the best parts of my job. I know what life is like here in Reynoldsburg – that you choose your car and your home to fit your lifestyle and your budget. I also know how important it is to do the same when it comes to insurance. I look forward to getting to know you and helping you to find the solutions that meet your needs.


Part of what I like best about my job is that I can offer customers options for a wide variety of coverage and services. You can depend on me to help you look at the big picture.


I’m committed to helping Reynoldsburg residents assess their immediate and long-term needs and choose options that will help them achieve their goals. When you want to explore options for protecting your home, personal property, or financial future, I’m available to answer your questions. If you’re already a customer, I’m ready to review your coverage so that you can make any necessary adjustments to fit your changing needs. Call me today.

Products we offer:

  • Car Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Car Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps protect you and your vehicle if you’re involved in a car accident. At a minimum, you’ll likely need bodily injury liability and property damage liability to meet state auto insurance coverage requirements and help protect your finances if you cause an accident that injures another driver or damages their property. We also offer uninsured motorist coverage to help with your expenses if you’re hit by a driver without insurance. If you’re looking for coverage to help protect your vehicle, you might want to consider collision coverage and comprehensive coverage, which help pay repair costs if your car is damaged in a covered loss. And, optional coverages, like new car replacement coverage or loan/lease gap coverage help protect your investment in a brand-new car. I can help you choose a combination of coverages that fulfill state requirements and meet your needs. Give me a call to get a car insurance quote today!

    get a quote
  • Home Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Home Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps provide protection for your house (dwelling) and your family’s liability as well as the things you own in and around your home such as “other structures” (detached garage, fence, etc.), your personal property (furniture, clothing, etc.) against covered perils such as fire, theft, wind/hail and more. Call me today for a homeowners insurance quote and I’ll help you get the protection your home needs and the savings you deserve with our money-saving discounts.

    get a quote
  • Condo Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Condo Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps protect the portion of your condo, co-op or townhome for which you are responsible for (inside structure, permanent fixtures, cabinets, etc.) with dependable coverage. Condo policies are HO-6 compliant, and cover family liability and personal belongings against covered perils such as fire, theft, vandalism and more. Contact me today for a quote!

    get a quote
  • Renters Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Renters Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps protect your personal belongings inside or outside your apartment from accidents such as, fire, theft, vandalism, and cover family liability. Give me call today to review what type of coverage makes sense for where you live and what you own.

    get a quote
  • Landlords & Hosts Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Landlords & Hosts Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps protect the structure of your rental property, from covered accidents such as fire, wind/hail, vandalism and more. It also offers protection for the liability you might face as an owner. Let’s chat about the right coverage for your additional property!

  • Motorcycle Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Motorcycle Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Our motorcycle policies include the basic coverage you may need, like liability coverage, which includes passenger liability coverage and uninsured motorist coverage. You can further customize your motorcycle policy with collision coverage and comprehensive coverage to help protect your bike. And, if you have a customized ride, you can help protect your aftermarket gear with optional equipment coverage. Contact me to learn about motorcycle insurance discounts and to get started with a quote for a policy that fits your needs.

    get a quote
  • Business Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Business Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Allstate Business Insurance protects your business in ways other insurance might not. A business owners policy (BOP) usually includes three common types of coverage to help protect you and your small business: property coverage, general liability coverage and business interruption coverage. In addition to these basic coverages, the Allstate Business Owners Policy can be customized with additional protection to help cover more aspects of your business. I can help you tailor a policy to fit your small business’s needs. As a small business owner myself, I understand how important it is to protect what you’ve worked so hard to build. Call me for a free review of your current business policy and to learn more about insurance solutions to help protect you, your business and your employees.

  • Life Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Life Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Protect the life you want, for those that matter most. A life insurance policy can help provide financial security for your loved ones by covering expenses like the mortgage, college tuition, and other everyday living costs. Call me today to learn about the different types of coverage Allstate offers.

  • ATV Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    ATV Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Help protect yourself and your all-terrain vehicle against the unexpected. We offer bodily injury liability coverage and property damage liability coverage on your ATV insurance policy. If you injure someone else or damage their property while driving your ATV, liability coverage helps pay the other person’s medical or repair bills. If your ATV is damaged in a crash, collision coverage may help. Collision coverage for your ATV helps pay for repairs if you hit another object, such as a fence or a tree. Finally, you may want to consider comprehensive coverage for your ATV in case it’s stolen, vandalized or damaged by hail or fire. Give me a call to get a quote on an ATV insurance policy today!

    get a quote
  • Boat Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Boat Insurance Agent in Reynoldsburg

    Helps cover your boat on and off the water. Watercraft liability coverage helps pay for another person’s expenses if you injure them or damage their property with your boat. If you’re injured in a boating accident, watercraft medical payments coverage helps pay for your medical bills. Need to repair damage to your boat after an accident? Property coverage for your boat helps cover a crash with another boat or object (like a pier or buoy). It also helps cover theft, vandalism or fire. Help protect your boat against these covered perils during the on- and off-season. We also offer additional coverage for things like your boat trailer, fishing equipment and even towing or fuel delivery when you’re stranded. Need a boat insurance quote? Give me a call today!

10+
Years of
Experience
20+
Years in the
Community

Your Local Allstate Team

Phillip Kisamore

Licensed Sales Professional (LSP)
Born and raised in Plain City, Phillip attended Ohio University and has more than five years' experience in the insurance industry. When not working, Phil enjoys spending time with his wife Danielle and their beloved cats. Self-
Born and raised in Plain City, Phillip attended Ohio University and has more than five years' experience in the insurance industry. When not working, Phil enjoys spending time with his wife Danielle and their beloved cats. Self-proclaimed "foodies," Phillip and Danielle reside in Blacklick.

Chauntrice Clark

Licensed Sales Professional
The newest member of our team, Chauntrice and her family reside near Reynoldsburg. When calling the agency, she will most likely be the one answering the phone. We invite customers to stop by and make her feel welcome. She is a
The newest member of our team, Chauntrice and her family reside near Reynoldsburg. When calling the agency, she will most likely be the one answering the phone. We invite customers to stop by and make her feel welcome. She is always willing to provide top-notch service. Chauntrice comes to us from the commercial lending arena and has extensive background in loan origination and servicing as well as credit life insurance.

Allstate Insurance Agent Reviews

Rating 4.0
Rating 5.0
Matt is a good person to deal with on any matters that he can handle with our policy's. And have recommend him to some o
Matt is a good person to deal with on any matters that he can handle with our policy's. And have recommend him to some of our friend.
Eddie & Chris
Rating 0.0
Lately my experience with allstate was very bad because of the not professional talk to customer of Matthew Smitherman.
Lately my experience with allstate was very bad because of the not professional talk to customer of Matthew Smitherman. A debt i didn't even know and didn't recognize was sent to collector. When I received notification from collector I called allstate and it was him but the way talked to me was unbelievable. It was the main reason I left and bought insurance from another company.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Jonas: Our records indicate the collections notice
Jonas: Our records indicate the collections notice you received was due to non-payment of premium from your auto account that cancelled all the way back in May of 2025. The last time anyone from our agency had any contact with you was in October of 2025 according to our records. Records also indicate that it was you who became argumentative at that time. Not us.
Rating 5.0
Great organization
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks for the great review, John. We really appr
Thanks for the great review, John. We really appreciate the five stars.
Rating 2.5
It’s not what it was with previous agent and I would consider another agent
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks, Manny. Our records indicate you called th
Thanks, Manny. Our records indicate you called the agency in April to add an automobile. Everything seemed to be fine with that transaction. Any further feedback you could provide would be greatly appreciated.
Rating 5.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks, Steven. We certainly appreciate the five
Thanks, Steven. We certainly appreciate the five stars. Please do stop by as we'd love to see you again.
Rating 4.0
Very good
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks, Yeshimebet. If we can do anything to make
Thanks, Yeshimebet. If we can do anything to make it five stars, please let us know. Your feedback is very helpful.
Rating 5.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
We appreciate the five stars, Frank. Always a ple
We appreciate the five stars, Frank. Always a pleasure.
Rating 5.0
Always on hand when needed for anything, even if it seems unimportant. Thank You for your time.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Your five stars are greatly appreciated, Rose. Ca
Your five stars are greatly appreciated, Rose. Call or come by anytime. Thanks.
Rating 5.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks for five stars, Lee Ann. Much appreciated.
Thanks for five stars, Lee Ann. Much appreciated. Please tell Ed we said hello.
Rating 5.0
I feel good with the service. I have no complaints.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Glad to hear we're doing a great job for you, Eva.
Glad to hear we're doing a great job for you, Eva. Your satisfaction is paramount. Feel free to call or stop by anytime. Thanks.
Rating 5.0
I am very experienced with Allstate. Since I am Allstate’s customer, everything I am doing is working better than othe
I am very experienced with Allstate. Since I am Allstate’s customer, everything I am doing is working better than other insurance companies. I never had any problems with Allstate and I got more benefits from Allstate. I will continue to work and recommend people to Allstate.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks for your continued patronage, Denis. Glad
Thanks for your continued patronage, Denis. Glad to hear your coverage is working well. Please call or stop by anytime we may be able to offer assistance.
Rating 5.0
Very prompt in service and professionally.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Your five stars is much appreciated, Boniface. Th
Your five stars is much appreciated, Boniface. Thanks again.
Rating 5.0
I have been with AllState for some years now I never had a problem with them, whatever help you need with your insurance
I have been with AllState for some years now I never had a problem with them, whatever help you need with your insurance renters insurance or whatever insurance you have with them they are there for you with answers. They have patience and very knowledgeable and it is the best insurance to have. They look out for their customers and offer specials bargains and keep you up on things even who has the cheapest gas at the gas stations. I give them a five star.thegas stations
Photo of agent
Agent Response
You're making us blush over here, Doris. Thanks f
You're making us blush over here, Doris. Thanks for the kind words and always a pleasure! Much appreciated.
Rating 5.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thank you Delores for the five stars. Please call
Thank you Delores for the five stars. Please call or stop by the office if we can assist you in any way. Thanks again.
Rating 5.0
The agency once owned by Davie has met all of my needs
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Appreciate the five stars, Mark. Our mission is t
Appreciate the five stars, Mark. Our mission is to continue the tradition established by the previous owner. Safe travels and thanks again.
Rating 0.0
Inconsistent information based on who answers the phone
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Joseph: There was nothing inconsistent between wha
Joseph: There was nothing inconsistent between what the staff member and I told you. We both conveyed we needed your daughter’s new address and insurance information to remove her from your coverage. As is the standard for all customers in that situation. Company policy in other words. Our records indicate your endorsement was processed as soon as you provided the necessary information. Thank you for the feedback.
Rating 5.0
I have had you for years would not want to change.
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks for the five stars, Billie. Hope all is we
Thanks for the five stars, Billie. Hope all is well with your roof.
Rating 3.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review, Gene
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review, Gene. We are here to address any concerns you might have. Please feel free to reach out if we may be of further assistance. Thanks again.
Rating 5.0
Photo of agent
Agent Response
Your five stars are greatly appreciated, Charles.
Your five stars are greatly appreciated, Charles. It was great meeting you and I really enjoyed our conversation. Thanks again.
Allstate Online Review Policy

Your Local Allstate Team

Phillip Kisamore

Licensed Sales Professional (LSP)
Born and raised in Plain City, Phillip attended Ohio University and has more than five years' experience in the insurance industry. When not working, Phil enjoys spending time with his wife Danielle and their beloved cats. Self-
Born and raised in Plain City, Phillip attended Ohio University and has more than five years' experience in the insurance industry. When not working, Phil enjoys spending time with his wife Danielle and their beloved cats. Self-proclaimed "foodies," Phillip and Danielle reside in Blacklick.

Chauntrice Clark

Licensed Sales Professional
The newest member of our team, Chauntrice and her family reside near Reynoldsburg. When calling the agency, she will most likely be the one answering the phone. We invite customers to stop by and make her feel welcome. She is a
The newest member of our team, Chauntrice and her family reside near Reynoldsburg. When calling the agency, she will most likely be the one answering the phone. We invite customers to stop by and make her feel welcome. She is always willing to provide top-notch service. Chauntrice comes to us from the commercial lending arena and has extensive background in loan origination and servicing as well as credit life insurance.

Frequently asked questions

What are your agency hours?
Monday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed
Are you open on weekends?
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed
Can I text your agency with questions?
No, we do not have text messaging services.
What languages do you speak?
We have staff members available who speak the following languages: English
Do you have more than one location?
No, this is our only location.
MATTHEW SMITHERMAN is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Ohio. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Ohio, please go to the Find an Agent section on allstate.com to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

Based on coverages selected. Subject to terms, conditions, availability & qualifications.

This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate North American Insurance Co. and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). This life insurance information is provided for general consumer educational purposes and is not intended to provide legal, tax or investment advice. Life insurance also offered and issued by third party companies not affiliated with Allstate. Each company is solely responsible for the financial obligations accruing under the products it issues. Product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing company.

Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 151 North 8th Street, Suite 450, Lincoln, NE 68508. (877) 232-2142.

Check the background of this firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck website.
you're in good hands®
Allstate Insurance Agent MATTHEW SMITHERMAN
MATTHEW SMITHERMAN, Car Insurance in Reynoldsburg, 43068
Contact
Location pin icon
1607 Brice Rd
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
US
Get Directions
(614) 367-0291Phone24/7
(614) 367-0291Phone24/7
Select a product to get a quoteSelect an Insurance Option Below

Select a product to get a quoteSelect an Insurance Option Below

Auto insurance
Home insurance
Condo insurance
Renters insurance
Motorcycle insurance
ATVATV
ATV insurance
Allstate Insurance Agent MATTHEW SMITHERMAN
MATTHEW SMITHERMAN Reynoldsburg, OH
Send an email