Allstate Insurance Agent Paul Sarnak

Allstate Insurance Agent 
Paul Sarnak, Lewes, DE

Elite Agent
Location pin icon
20361 John J Williams Hwy
Lewes, DE 19958
US
Call
(302) 248-8500to quote by phone
Call
(302) 248-8500to quote by phone
Call
(302) 248-8500to quote by phone
Call
(302) 248-8500to quote by phone
Select a product to get a quoteSelect a product to get a quote
Auto insurance
Home insurance
Renters insurance
Landlords & Hosts insurance
Motorcycle insurance
ATV insurance

Location Details

Office Hours

Day of the WeekHours
MonAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
TueAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
WedAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
ThuAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
FriAvailable by appointment8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
SatAvailable by appointment
SunAvailable by appointment
After-hours appointments available.
Available 24/7 at
(302) 248-8500
(302) 248-8500

20361 John J Williams Hwy
Lewes, DE 19958
US

Map of 20361 John J Williams Hwy in Lewes

Landmarks

Between Marina Ln and Turtle Dr on RT 24. Call us directly at 302 927-0927

Areas Served

Lewes, Milton, Millsboro, Dagsboro, Milford, Rehoboth Beach, Selbyville

Additional Contact

Fax: (302) 231-0707
Mobile: (302) 258-9775
Mobile: (302) 258-9775
Toll Free: (888) 255-8066
Toll Free: (888) 255-8066

Languages

English, Spanish

Social

Paul Sarnak: Allstate Insurance
You can view my financial industry experience and background at FINRA’s BrokerCheck

Local Allstate Insurance Agent: Paul Sarnak

When you need help choosing the right insurance products and services to protect the people and possessions you care about, you need personalized attention from someone who treats you like family. I opened my agency in 2010 so customers in the Lewes area can get outstanding service while protecting the things that are important to them.


As a trusted Allstate agent, I believe in giving back to my community. My agency supports Habitat for Humanity, the Delaware and the Coalition Against Domestic Violence. I'm also a member of Rehoboth-Dewey Chamber of Commerce and I volunteer as a defensive driver instructor.


I’ve been visiting the Delamarva area since 1982 and knew I wanted to live in the area since then. I have been a member of the community since 2010.


When I’m not working, my family and I love to visit the Cape Henlopen State Park and bike the trails or fish at the beach. I enjoy staying active and spend time playing sports or working out whenever I get the chance.


I invite you to stop by my agency any time. We can assist you with condo, renters, home, auto or business insurance and more. My office is conveniently located off Coastal Highway. My team and I look forward to getting to know you!

When you need help choosing the right insurance products and services to protect the people and possessions you care about, you need personalized attention from someone who treats you like family. I opened my agency in 2010 so customers in the Lewes area can get outstanding service while protecting the things that are important to them.


As a trusted Allstate agent, I believe in giving back to my community. My agency supports Habitat for Humanity, the Delaware and the Coalition Against Domestic Violence. I'm also a member of Rehoboth-Dewey Chamber of Commerce and I volunteer as a defensive driver instructor.


I’ve been visiting the Delamarva area since 1982 and knew I wanted to live in the area since then. I have been a member of the community since 2010.


When I’m not working, my family and I love to visit the Cape Henlopen State Park and bike the trails or fish at the beach. I enjoy staying active and spend time playing sports or working out whenever I get the chance.


I invite you to stop by my agency any time. We can assist you with condo, renters, home, auto or business insurance and more. My office is conveniently located off Coastal Highway. My team and I look forward to getting to know you!

Products we offer:

10+
Years of
Experience
15+
Years in the
Community
Elite Agent
Agency Achievement Award-3 years
Allstate Leader's Forum-4 years
Circle Of Champions Award-3 years
Honor Ring-10 years
Inner Circle Elite Award-4 years
National Conference Award-4 years
National Forum-3 years
Chamber of Commerce
Volunteer DE Defensive Driver Instructor
Habitat For Humanity Volunteer
Delaware Coalition Against Domestic Violence
Allstate National Advisory Board

Your Local Allstate Team

Photo of Heather Riggin

Heather Riggin

Agency Operations Manager
Heather Riggin was born and raised in Maryland and is a proud mother of two. She has been in the insurance field since 2015 and has been part of the office since 2020, where she is dedicated to helping customers protect what matte
Heather Riggin was born and raised in Maryland and is a proud mother of two. She has been in the insurance field since 2015 and has been part of the office since 2020, where she is dedicated to helping customers protect what matters most.

Outside of work, Heather enjoys spending time outdoors hiking with her husband of 20 years and her two standard poodles, exploring new experiences, and getting creative with arts and crafts. She also loves going to concerts and has recently taken up traveling, embracing every opportunity to see new places and make lasting memories.
Photo of Vanessa Zunun-Ordaz

Vanessa Zunun-Ordaz

Senior Account Manager
Vanessa is a native Delawarean, that really loves spending her time at the beach. She graduated from University of Delaware and would like to keep studying just for the fun of it. She loves going out and taking trips or staying in
Vanessa is a native Delawarean, that really loves spending her time at the beach. She graduated from University of Delaware and would like to keep studying just for the fun of it. She loves going out and taking trips or staying in and binge-watching shows. Her goal is to travel as much as possible. Vanessa joined our agency in 2023 and assists the Agency Owner and Manager. She also helps the Account Managers and loves to help customers with great service. She is a Spanish speaker and helps the Spanish speaking community with their needs as well. Do not hesitate to call and see if she can help you today.
Photo of Maddie Abel

Maddie Abel

Executive Account Manager
Maddie Abel joined the Agency in 2026 and has been working in the insurance industry since 2025. As an Executive Account Manager, she assists customers with their Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Condo, and Life insurance needs, providi
Maddie Abel joined the Agency in 2026 and has been working in the insurance industry since 2025. As an Executive Account Manager, she assists customers with their Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Condo, and Life insurance needs, providing knowledgeable service and support throughout every stage of their insurance journey.

Maddie enjoys the ever-changing nature of the insurance industry and appreciates that there is always something new to learn. She finds it rewarding to help customers protect what matters most while continuing to expand her knowledge and skills.

Fun Facts About Maddie:

Maddie lives in a tiny home that she built with her wife.
She enjoys roller skating in her free time and loves staying active.
Photo of Chloe Park

Chloe Park

Customer Support
Chloe joined the agency in 2026 and serves as a Assistant Account Manager. She assists with servicing customers, helping with claims, and provides support throughout the claims process. Chloe is dedicated to delivering excellent c
Chloe joined the agency in 2026 and serves as a Assistant Account Manager. She assists with servicing customers, helping with claims, and provides support throughout the claims process. Chloe is dedicated to delivering excellent customer service and helping customers feel supported when they need us most.

Her favorite part of the job is helping customers file claims, so they receive the care and assistance they deserve during difficult situations.

Fun Facts About Chloe:

She is the proud mother of a 2-year-old son.
Before entering the insurance industry, Chloe worked in the medical field and has experience in nursing.
Photo of Caitlin Louia

Caitlin Louia

Senior Sales Consultant
Caitlin was born in Baltimore and moved to Lewes in 2015. She graduated from Cape in 2019. She loves to spend time with her daughter and boyfriend when she is not in the office. They are always traveling together. Caitlin received
Caitlin was born in Baltimore and moved to Lewes in 2015. She graduated from Cape in 2019. She loves to spend time with her daughter and boyfriend when she is not in the office. They are always traveling together. Caitlin received her license with us in 2022 and loves serving our community for their insurance needs. She is eager to help and jumps in anytime she is needed. She has a bubbly personality and is a wonderful additional to our agency. Call her for your insurance needs.
Photo of Cameron Crow

Cameron Crow

Senior Sales Consultant
As a Phoenix native and parent of three, I understand the importance of protecting what matters most. I bring that personal perspective to my work, helping families and individuals find the right insurance solutions for their uniq
As a Phoenix native and parent of three, I understand the importance of protecting what matters most. I bring that personal perspective to my work, helping families and individuals find the right insurance solutions for their unique needs. When I'm not assisting customers, you'll find me enjoying sports and activities with my kids.
Photo of Celeste Ellis

Celeste Ellis

Senior Sales Consultant
Born in Ohio originally, moved to DE in 2000 to be near family, married a local man and have fallen in love with everything Delaware. I've worked in the insurance industry for nearly 30 years and still try to learn something new e
Born in Ohio originally, moved to DE in 2000 to be near family, married a local man and have fallen in love with everything Delaware. I've worked in the insurance industry for nearly 30 years and still try to learn something new every day. I enjoy customers and take pride in helping protect them from the unexpected, in my free time I enjoy traveling with my husband, time with family, and playing tourist at the Delaware beaches. I play a mean game of putt putt golf. I have 3 furry kids of my own & volunteer with a local animal rescue.
Photo of Pete DiFerdinando

Pete DiFerdinando

Licensed Sales Consultant
Pete DiFerdinando began his insurance career in 2022 and joined the Agency in 2025. Focusing on Commercial insurance and Life insurance, he enjoys the challenge of tailoring policies to fit the unique needs of individuals, familie
Pete DiFerdinando began his insurance career in 2022 and joined the Agency in 2025. Focusing on Commercial insurance and Life insurance, he enjoys the challenge of tailoring policies to fit the unique needs of individuals, families, and businesses. His goal is to help every customer have the right coverage to help protect what matters most.

With a background in Computer Science, Pete has a deep appreciation for problem-solving, which translates into his approach to insurance. Outside of work, he is passionate about music and enjoys playing the guitar in his spare time. Whether he's crafting the perfect insurance policy or a great melody, Pete is dedicated to delivering value and insight.
Photo of Elizabeth Heasley

Elizabeth Heasley

Licensed Sales Consultant
Since beginning her insurance career in 2024, she has been dedicated to helping customers find the right coverage to protect what matters most. Born and raised in Philadelphia, she brings a strong work ethic, a friendly personalit
Since beginning her insurance career in 2024, she has been dedicated to helping customers find the right coverage to protect what matters most. Born and raised in Philadelphia, she brings a strong work ethic, a friendly personality, and a genuine passion for helping others to every customer interaction.

She enjoys building lasting relationships with customers and takes pride in making the insurance process simple, informative, and personalized to each individual's needs.

Outside of the office, she is passionate about martial arts, where she has developed discipline, focus, and perseverance. She also loves making people laugh and is always looking for opportunities to learn, grow, and challenge herself.

Her positive attitude, commitment to exceptional customer service, and willingness to go the extra mile make her a valued member of the Delmarva Insurance Group team.

Karly Anemone

Executive Account Manager

Allstate Insurance Agent Reviews

Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
I’m very satisfied with my experience with Allstate for my homeowners insurance. I appreciate the coverage options and
I’m very satisfied with my experience with Allstate for my homeowners insurance. I appreciate the coverage options and the competitive premium offered for my home. The process of getting coverage was a positive experience, and I’m happy to have chosen Allstate to help protect my home. Thank you for providing an affordable insurance option and giving me peace of mind as a homeowner.
Rating 4.5
Rating 5.0
Great
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Good and prompt response
Rating 2.5
No feeling at all we have not communicated at all
Rating 4.0
Things were a little slow to change the policy but all in all they are good
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Your staff was extremely helpful. Karly was tremendous!
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Rating 5.0
Prompt response
Rating 5.0
Rating 1.5
It took serveral weeks and phone calls for allstate to find my payment
Rating 4.0
I would say very good , staff was accommodating and friendly ❤️
Allstate Online Review Policy

Your Local Allstate Team

Photo of Heather Riggin

Heather Riggin

Agency Operations Manager
Heather Riggin was born and raised in Maryland and is a proud mother of two. She has been in the insurance field since 2015 and has been part of the office since 2020, where she is dedicated to helping customers protect what matte
Heather Riggin was born and raised in Maryland and is a proud mother of two. She has been in the insurance field since 2015 and has been part of the office since 2020, where she is dedicated to helping customers protect what matters most.

Outside of work, Heather enjoys spending time outdoors hiking with her husband of 20 years and her two standard poodles, exploring new experiences, and getting creative with arts and crafts. She also loves going to concerts and has recently taken up traveling, embracing every opportunity to see new places and make lasting memories.
Photo of Vanessa Zunun-Ordaz

Vanessa Zunun-Ordaz

Senior Account Manager
Vanessa is a native Delawarean, that really loves spending her time at the beach. She graduated from University of Delaware and would like to keep studying just for the fun of it. She loves going out and taking trips or staying in
Vanessa is a native Delawarean, that really loves spending her time at the beach. She graduated from University of Delaware and would like to keep studying just for the fun of it. She loves going out and taking trips or staying in and binge-watching shows. Her goal is to travel as much as possible. Vanessa joined our agency in 2023 and assists the Agency Owner and Manager. She also helps the Account Managers and loves to help customers with great service. She is a Spanish speaker and helps the Spanish speaking community with their needs as well. Do not hesitate to call and see if she can help you today.
Photo of Maddie Abel

Maddie Abel

Executive Account Manager
Maddie Abel joined the Agency in 2026 and has been working in the insurance industry since 2025. As an Executive Account Manager, she assists customers with their Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Condo, and Life insurance needs, providi
Maddie Abel joined the Agency in 2026 and has been working in the insurance industry since 2025. As an Executive Account Manager, she assists customers with their Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Condo, and Life insurance needs, providing knowledgeable service and support throughout every stage of their insurance journey.

Maddie enjoys the ever-changing nature of the insurance industry and appreciates that there is always something new to learn. She finds it rewarding to help customers protect what matters most while continuing to expand her knowledge and skills.

Fun Facts About Maddie:

Maddie lives in a tiny home that she built with her wife.
She enjoys roller skating in her free time and loves staying active.
Photo of Chloe Park

Chloe Park

Customer Support
Chloe joined the agency in 2026 and serves as a Assistant Account Manager. She assists with servicing customers, helping with claims, and provides support throughout the claims process. Chloe is dedicated to delivering excellent c
Chloe joined the agency in 2026 and serves as a Assistant Account Manager. She assists with servicing customers, helping with claims, and provides support throughout the claims process. Chloe is dedicated to delivering excellent customer service and helping customers feel supported when they need us most.

Her favorite part of the job is helping customers file claims, so they receive the care and assistance they deserve during difficult situations.

Fun Facts About Chloe:

She is the proud mother of a 2-year-old son.
Before entering the insurance industry, Chloe worked in the medical field and has experience in nursing.
Photo of Caitlin Louia

Caitlin Louia

Senior Sales Consultant
Caitlin was born in Baltimore and moved to Lewes in 2015. She graduated from Cape in 2019. She loves to spend time with her daughter and boyfriend when she is not in the office. They are always traveling together. Caitlin received
Caitlin was born in Baltimore and moved to Lewes in 2015. She graduated from Cape in 2019. She loves to spend time with her daughter and boyfriend when she is not in the office. They are always traveling together. Caitlin received her license with us in 2022 and loves serving our community for their insurance needs. She is eager to help and jumps in anytime she is needed. She has a bubbly personality and is a wonderful additional to our agency. Call her for your insurance needs.
Photo of Cameron Crow

Cameron Crow

Senior Sales Consultant
As a Phoenix native and parent of three, I understand the importance of protecting what matters most. I bring that personal perspective to my work, helping families and individuals find the right insurance solutions for their uniq
As a Phoenix native and parent of three, I understand the importance of protecting what matters most. I bring that personal perspective to my work, helping families and individuals find the right insurance solutions for their unique needs. When I'm not assisting customers, you'll find me enjoying sports and activities with my kids.
Photo of Celeste Ellis

Celeste Ellis

Senior Sales Consultant
Born in Ohio originally, moved to DE in 2000 to be near family, married a local man and have fallen in love with everything Delaware. I've worked in the insurance industry for nearly 30 years and still try to learn something new e
Born in Ohio originally, moved to DE in 2000 to be near family, married a local man and have fallen in love with everything Delaware. I've worked in the insurance industry for nearly 30 years and still try to learn something new every day. I enjoy customers and take pride in helping protect them from the unexpected, in my free time I enjoy traveling with my husband, time with family, and playing tourist at the Delaware beaches. I play a mean game of putt putt golf. I have 3 furry kids of my own & volunteer with a local animal rescue.
Photo of Pete DiFerdinando

Pete DiFerdinando

Licensed Sales Consultant
Pete DiFerdinando began his insurance career in 2022 and joined the Agency in 2025. Focusing on Commercial insurance and Life insurance, he enjoys the challenge of tailoring policies to fit the unique needs of individuals, familie
Pete DiFerdinando began his insurance career in 2022 and joined the Agency in 2025. Focusing on Commercial insurance and Life insurance, he enjoys the challenge of tailoring policies to fit the unique needs of individuals, families, and businesses. His goal is to help every customer have the right coverage to help protect what matters most.

With a background in Computer Science, Pete has a deep appreciation for problem-solving, which translates into his approach to insurance. Outside of work, he is passionate about music and enjoys playing the guitar in his spare time. Whether he's crafting the perfect insurance policy or a great melody, Pete is dedicated to delivering value and insight.
Photo of Elizabeth Heasley

Elizabeth Heasley

Licensed Sales Consultant
Since beginning her insurance career in 2024, she has been dedicated to helping customers find the right coverage to protect what matters most. Born and raised in Philadelphia, she brings a strong work ethic, a friendly personalit
Since beginning her insurance career in 2024, she has been dedicated to helping customers find the right coverage to protect what matters most. Born and raised in Philadelphia, she brings a strong work ethic, a friendly personality, and a genuine passion for helping others to every customer interaction.

She enjoys building lasting relationships with customers and takes pride in making the insurance process simple, informative, and personalized to each individual's needs.

Outside of the office, she is passionate about martial arts, where she has developed discipline, focus, and perseverance. She also loves making people laugh and is always looking for opportunities to learn, grow, and challenge herself.

Her positive attitude, commitment to exceptional customer service, and willingness to go the extra mile make her a valued member of the Delmarva Insurance Group team.

Karly Anemone

Executive Account Manager

Frequently asked questions

What are your agency hours?
Monday: 8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday: 8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday:
Sunday:
Are you open on weekends?
Saturday:
Sunday:
Can I text your agency with questions?
Yes, we have text messaging services.
What languages do you speak?
We have staff members available who speak the following languages: English, Spanish
Do you have more than one location?
No, this is our only location.
Paul Sarnak is insurance licensed in the state(s) of Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. If you do not reside in the state(s) of Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, or Virginia, please go to the Find an Agent section on allstate.com to search for another Allstate Agent or Personal Financial Representative.

Based on coverages selected. Subject to terms, conditions, availability & qualifications.

This material is intended for educational purposes only. Auto and homeowners insurance, and other property and casualty insurance products, are available from Allstate Insurance Company, Allstate Indemnity Company, Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Allstate North American Insurance Co. and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Northbrook, IL); Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company and Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company (Home Offices: Bridgewater, NJ); and Allstate County Mutual Insurance Company and Allstate Texas Lloyd's (Home Offices: Irving, TX). This life insurance information is provided for general consumer educational purposes and is not intended to provide legal, tax or investment advice. Life insurance also offered and issued by third party companies not affiliated with Allstate. Each company is solely responsible for the financial obligations accruing under the products it issues. Product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing company.

Securities offered by Personal Financial Representatives through Allstate Financial Services, LLC (LSA Securities in LA and PA). Registered Broker-Dealer. Member FINRA, SIPC. Main Office: 151 North 8th Street, Suite 450, Lincoln, NE 68508. (877) 232-2142.

Check the background of this firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck website.
you're in good hands®